Overnight Accommodations

Hotels

Book ASAP! The weekend of the reunion is a very busy one on the Island, with lots of tournaments.

Bay Shore

Ocean Bay House B&B

Distance from Captain Bill's
0.3 miles — a 6-minute walk
Rate & Conditions
  • Range from $340–$480 / night
  • 9 rooms, each with a private bath
  • 3 of these rooms have sleeper sofas
Amenities
  • Breakfast provided (8–10 am)
  • Pool
  • B&B located in the marina
Reservations
Call to make reservations and let them know you are with the West Islip High School Reunion group.
Sales Contact
Elizabeth
Good to Know
Currently blocked for the public to make reservations. Held until May 16, then opened to the public and the deposit refunded.

Hauppauge

Holiday Inn Express

Distance from Captain Bill's
10 miles, ~18 min
Rate & Conditions
  • Requires a 2-night minimum stay for Friday and Saturday
  • $299 per night for Friday and Saturday
Amenities
  • Pool & fitness center
  • Complimentary breakfast
  • Coffee 24 hrs in the lobby
  • $5 daily parking fee
Sales Contact
Lindsay Ramrattan — Sales Manager

Farmingdale

Courtyard by Marriott

Distance from Captain Bill's
11 miles, ~20 min
Rate & Conditions
  • Group rate per night:
  • $309 — King
  • $329 — 2 Queens
Amenities
  • Bistro restaurant (morning & evening)
  • Bar
  • Fitness center
  • Outdoor firepit
  • Just completed a full renovation
Sales Contact
Stephanie Walback — Director of Sales

Ronkonkoma

Hilton Garden Inn

Distance from Captain Bill's
12 miles, ~22 min (5.5 miles from the golf event)
Rate & Conditions
  • Thursday night: $189 King, $199 2-Queens
  • Friday & Saturday (per night): $229 King, $249 2-Queens
Amenities
  • Restaurant & bar
Sales Contact
David Hall — Director of Sales

Commack

Hampton Inn

Distance from Captain Bill's
9 miles, ~18 min
Rate & Conditions
  • Requires a 2-night minimum
  • Regular price: starts at $309 for a King room
Amenities
  • Breakfast
  • Lobby coffee
  • Indoor pool
  • Fitness center
Reservations
Call the hotel to ask for the West Islip Reunion group rate.
Sales Contact
Jessica Michaelos — Sales Director
Good to Know
Requires a financial deposit if booking a group hold.